5 Best Crib Mattresses For Your Baby (2023)

Welcome to the world of parenthood! From the endless diaper changes to the sleepless nights, it’s a never-ending cycle of exhaustion. But fear not, comrades! I’m here to make one of your toughest decisions a little bit easier: finding the best crib mattress for your baby.

We’ve had plenty of sleepless nights… Honestly we still get them sometimes. Sometime your baby doesn’t want to stay in bed. But getting the right crib mattress helps a lot.

Why is it a big deal to choose the right mattress?
– Baby’s comfort
– Your peace of mind

What is the Best Crib Mattress?

My choice for the best crib mattress is the Newton Baby Crib Mattress. The most important part of your baby’s mattress is the peace of mind it gives you from its safety features. Sleep peacefully knowing that your baby is on this comfortable, breathable mattress.

Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Overview

The Newton Baby mattress is a breathable and washable mattress. Can’t beat that. The mattress is made with this cool springy-like design to make it the best in breathability. And all of the materials are non-toxic.

We picked the Newton Baby because of the how awesome it is, but also because the reputation it already had with people we knew.

Benefits

-2 Stage Infant and toddler mattress
-Breathable
-Lightweight
-Organic
-Easy to wash

Wrap-Up

The Newton Baby is our #1 crib mattress because it’s everything you need. You and your baby will love it.

OrganicDream ComfortSupreme

Source: Organic-Dream.com

Overview

OrganicDream’s SupremeComfort is a strong contender for the #1 spot. SupremeComfort is another breathable mattress, but with a twist… One side is SOFTER than the other!

You want your toddler to have a softer mattress? Flip that beauty upside-down! (The mattress, not the toddler)

Benefits

-2 Stage infant and toddler mattress
-100% Breathable
-Extra Comfortable
-Washable
-Organic
-GREENGUARD Gold Certified

Wrap-Up

The OrganicDream SupremeComfort is a great choice. It might have won our top pick if the Newton Baby didn’t have the coolest design for breathability.

NaturePedic Organic Breathable Baby Crib Mattress

Source: NaturePedic.com

Overview

The NaturePedic Classic Organic Cotton Crib Mattress is non-toxic on steroids. Apparently they are handmade by Amish craftsmen.

I think we can all be a little “crunchy” sometimes and that’s ok. We just want our kids to be safe. And yes this one is breathable too.

Benefits:

-Breathable
-2-Stage
-Organic cotton from sugarcane… FANCY
-Top craftsmanship
-Environmentally friendly
-GREENGUARD Gold Certified

Wrap-Up

If you want to have a great mattress, these are all good picks.

BUT…! If you want to brag to your friends about the Amish guy that made your baby’s mattress BY HAND!?!?! Get the NaturePedic.

Avocado Eco Organic Crib Mattress

Source: Avocadogreenmattress.com

Overview

The Avocado Eco is made of 100% organic cotton, hemp and, most importantly, wool.

When I was in college, I worked at a suit shop for 3 years. Wool is a miracle material. That’s why it’s the sought after material for suits.

Wool contracts into itself when its cold to keep you warm, and opens up in the heat to keep you cool.

The pad is a breathable coconut husk too, which is always nice. The only downside being the more expensive option of these.

Benefits

-Organic
-Natural temperature regulating wool
-Durable with 10 year warranty
-Comfortable
-MADE SAFE Certified
-GREENGUARD Gold Certified
-Washable pad

Wrap-Up

If for whatever reason, temperature regulation is a concern for you, this is the play.

Our little girl sleeps hot and always wakes up sweaty, so I wish we knew about this mattress when she was small.

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress

Source: Amazon.com

Overview

No. Not every good mattress has to cost $300+. If you need a more budget friendly option, this was our first mattress.

It will last. It’s easy to clean especially with the water resistant cover. You’re just missing out on the breathability of the others.

Benefits

-Budget friendly
-GREENGUARD Gold Certified
-Lightweight
-Washable cover
-Water resistant
-2-Stage

Wrap-Up

You don’t need to feel like you’re breaking the bank. If the breathability isn’t a concern, this is a great mattress still.

Conclusion

Choosing the right crib mattress will help big time with bedtime. My wife gets hit hard with post partum anxiety. Always looking at the monitor to make sure the babies are breathing.

Every parent has had to go through stages of sleep deprivation. Some nights are longer than others. On some nights, dad is up with the baby, and mom is pumping because the baby wouldn’t eat. It doesn’t last forever even though every night feels like an eternity.

These 5 options are all great. I know that whatever you pick, in the end, you’ll be happy. Don’t stress. I wouldn’t put a bad mattress on this list.